Toronto Blue Jays outfielder Anthony Santander posted hostile videos targeting Muslims on social media shortly after the U.S. midterm elections. He deleted them two days later. The National Council of Canadian Muslims (NCCM) describes these posts as troubling, while stating that they offer an opportunity for dialogue.
A native of Venezuela, Santander signed a five-year contract worth US$92.5 million in January 2025. He missed the 2025 Major League season due to injuries and played only 54 games with Toronto. His agent or management company did not respond to requests for comment.
According to reporting notes, one of the videos featured a Christian preacher claiming there are no benevolent Muslims. Another claimed that sharia law would be imposed following the Senate victory of Abdul El-Sayed, who would become the first Muslim U.S. senator, elected in Michigan. This content circulated in a political context where the place of Muslim communities in American public debate is frequently discussed.
The NCCM, through its media spokesperson Steven Zhou, is calling for an apology, awareness, and dialogue. The organization says its doors remain open to meet with the player and the team's management. In the Toronto area, the head of a Muslim softball league said supporters were unhappy with the team's response. Oakville influencer Emad Ahmed said he was dismayed by the posts. A crisis communications advisor described the Blue Jays' response as the bare minimum.
In a statement, the Blue Jays said these comments do not reflect the team's values. No sanctions have been announced to date. General manager Ross Atkins is scheduled to speak at the MLB general managers' meetings in Las Vegas.
There is a precedent in the league. In 2023, reliever Anthony Bass was placed on waivers and then released following a video calling for a boycott. Atkins had cited the player's performance at the time, while acknowledging that the controversy played a role in the decision. Sports law attorney Emir Crowne believes the likely sanctions would be a fine, a short suspension, or training. It is not yet known whether a disciplinary measure will be imposed on Santander.
2
