The National Congress of American Indians is calling on U.S. President Donald Trump to withdraw his August executive order renaming Lake Ontario as Lake America. The organization, which represents American Indian and Alaska Native tribal governments across the United States, says the order disrespects Indigenous geographic names and the cultural, spiritual and historical relationships Indigenous peoples hold with the land and waters.

A resolution rejecting the name change was passed at the organization's October assembly and was introduced by the Seneca Nation of Indians, a community based in western New York. The resolution says unilateral efforts to rename geography risk erasing Indigenous history. It calls on the U.S. federal government to suspend its use of the term Lake America.

The executive order directed all arms of the federal government to begin using the name Lake America. It was issued in August and drew objections from Haudenosaunee communities, whose languages are the source of the name Ontario. The name carries meaning in those languages. In Seneca, Lake Ontario means beautiful lake, and in Wendat it means the lake is beautiful, the lake is big. Those descriptions tie the name to the lake itself and to the people who have lived beside it for generations.

The dispute places the lake, which Canada and the United States share, at the centre of a broader question about who names shared geography and whose languages are recognized in doing so. The resolution's wording frames the issue as one of Indigenous history and relationships to land, not only a matter of nomenclature. Its authors argue that a change made by decree, without consultation, sets a precedent that could affect other place names with Indigenous origins.

For Canadians living along the lake's shores in Ontario, the dispute is a reminder that the lake's name is rooted in Indigenous languages long before the present border was drawn. The lake's Canadian and American shorelines are home to communities on both sides, and the name Ontario is already in everyday use across the province. The National Congress of American Indians has not indicated any specific next step beyond its call for the order to be reversed.

20Views