Democrats are preparing to target some of Donald Trump's tariffs when the new Congress convenes, after a midterm election in which voters signalled their rejection of his trade policies. Senator Ron Wyden said Democrats will prioritize lifting tariffs on Canada in January. Yet lawmakers and analysts caution that removing some of the duties may not end the broader trade war between Washington and Ottawa.
The Democratic gains were visible across several states. In Mississippi, Democrat Colom won a Senate seat after a week of ballot counting, becoming the first Black person elected statewide in the state since Reconstruction. Democrats also flipped seats in Texas, South Carolina and Iowa. Exit polling showed affordability was the main concern for voters, and tariffs dominated campaign advertising in Michigan and Maine. In Maine, under 10 per cent of voters said tariffs had helped the local economy. Colom's own anti-tariff advertisements focused on the harm the duties were causing to farmers.
The results also pointed to a weakening of the Republican coalition, particularly among Hispanic voters and young men. Canada is a top trading partner of Mississippi, which gave the tariff debate a direct local dimension in that race.
The Trump administration continues to defend its tariffs, but its rhetoric toward Canada has softened. The United States Trade Representative, Jamieson Greer, has said Trump and Prime Minister Mark Carney talk regularly. The trade relationship nonetheless deteriorated sharply in August, when talks collapsed and the Canada trade war escalated.
The central dispute concerns duties imposed under Section 338 of the 1930 Tariff Act. Trump used the provision to impose levies of 50 per cent on Canadian goods. Later, Section 338 was used to impose import bans affecting motorcycles, some alcohol and dairy products. A lawsuit argues that Section 338 duties exceed presidential authority. Overturning those tariffs through Congress would require a two-thirds majority to override a presidential veto, which means Republican defections would be needed to reach a supermajority.
Analysts say sectoral tariffs on steel, aluminum, autos and cabinetry are unlikely to be lifted, and a separate 10 per cent duty tied to forced-labour claims also remains in question. Some incoming Democrats support protectionist tariffs to shield domestic industries, a position that complicates any unified Democratic push for free trade. The debate also reflects a bipartisan record: Joe Biden kept and expanded tariffs introduced during Trump's first term, and Kamala Harris voted against the Canada-U.S.-Mexico trade agreement as a senator.
For Canadians, the outcome matters because the United States is a central market for Canadian exports, and tariffs on Canadian goods affect businesses and workers on both sides of the border. Whether a January vote succeeds will depend on Republican support, the outcome of legal challenges and whether the two governments can resume negotiations.
59
