Federal projections show Canada is on track to miss its 2030 emissions target under the Paris climate accord, yet the government has not said whether it remains committed to that goal. Environment Minister Julie Dabrusin has repeatedly pointed instead to Canada's target of net-zero emissions by 2050, and her office has declined to say whether the 2030 target still stands.
The government's own projections, published in its emissions reductions progress report a year ago, showed a best-case scenario of a 28 per cent reduction from 2005 levels by 2030. Canada's Paris commitment is a cut of 40 to 45 per cent from 2005 levels. The projections predate a series of climate policy rollbacks introduced by the Carney government over the past year, including a delay to more stringent tailpipe emissions standards. That measure was meant to replace the electric vehicle sales mandate, which has now been scrapped, and it will not take effect until at least 2029.
In June, Prime Minister Mark Carney told Canadians that emissions would be higher « in the next few years » than previously projected, acknowledging that emissions are on the rise. Those earlier projections already showed Canada would miss its 2030 target. The Stephen Harper government had set a target of a 30 per cent reduction.
Dabrusin's position drew criticism from two of her predecessors while she attended the United Nations climate conference in Turkey last week, where she said Canada remained committed to its Paris commitments. When asked whether that commitment included the 2030 target, she did not answer. In a statement, her office said Canada is « committed to its Paris agreement of achieving net-zero by 2050 » but again did not address the 2030 question directly.
Her press secretary, Amy Falkner, wrote that « we cannot achieve our climate goals when we are divided » and pointed to clean energy projects, electrification and co-operation with provinces, territories and Indigenous Peoples. Falkner said Canada will report on its 2030 target next month to the United Nations Climate Change Secretariat, as required under the Paris Agreement, and will report progress under the Net-Zero Accountability Act in December 2027.
Keith Stewart, senior energy strategist with Greenpeace Canada, said the government may be reluctant to state publicly that it no longer expects to meet the 2030 target because doing so would make clear that it is choosing policies that worsen wildfires and flooding. He argued that the rollbacks go further than anything the Harper government attempted, and said Dabrusin, as a cabinet minister, could resign in protest if she disagreed with the decisions. Stewart added that nobody believes she is « calling the shots », and that the direction is coming from the prime minister.
The question of whether the Net-Zero Accountability Act has any real effect was also raised in Parliament this week. The act sets out no fines or penalties for missing or abandoning climate targets. At Thursday's meeting of the House of Commons environment committee, B.C. Conservative MP Ellis Ross asked what purpose the act serves if the government is falling short of its targets. Elsa Da Costa, the interim environment commissioner, responded that the act is an « important tool » that allows her office to hold the government to account.
The political stakes extend beyond Parliament. An Angus Reid Institute online poll of 1,770 Canadians, released in July, found climate was the top issue for 21 per cent of respondents and the top concern for half of NDP supporters. The poll also suggested the Liberals' climate record may be pushing one in six Liberal voters toward the NDP. The Canadian Research Insights Council, an industry body that promotes polling standards, notes that online surveys cannot be assigned a margin of error because they do not randomly sample the population.
There are legal implications as well. The federal government is defending a lawsuit brought by a group of climate advocates that asks the Federal Court to order Ottawa to bring its 2030 emissions reduction plan into compliance with the Net-Zero Accountability Act. Stewart said that publicly abandoning the 2030 target would carry both political and legal consequences for the government.
5
