The federal Liberal government has limited debate on its proposed changes to Canada's medical assistance in dying law, despite calls from Opposition MPs for more time to study the bill. Members of Parliament adopted a motion by Justice Minister Sean Fraser on Monday that limits second-reading debate to one more day. The second-reading vote is expected Tuesday, after question period. If the bill passes that vote, it will go to committee.
Bill C-41, introduced in the House of Commons on Oct. 27, would amend the Criminal Code in two main ways. It would allow people to make advance requests for medical assistance in dying, or MAID, and it would prevent a scheduled expansion of access to people suffering solely from a mental illness. The bill must pass both the House of Commons and the Senate before March 17, the date on which the current law would extend MAID access to people whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness. Debate at second reading took place on Oct. 30, Nov. 4 and Nov. 16.
Conservatives say they support barring MAID access for people suffering solely from a mental illness. They have, however, urged the government to split the bill so that parliamentarians have more time to study the advance-request provisions. Conservative MP Tamara Jansen called it “absolutely shameful” that the government is shutting down debate on a bill that deals with life and death. She accused the Liberals of denying MPs the information they need, noting that the government has not yet released its own analysis of how the bill could affect Charter rights. “Surely, if there was ever a bill that deserves careful scrutiny, this is it,” Jansen said.
Bloc Québécois MP Martin Champoux also criticized the move. Speaking in French, he said it was disturbing to see the government “muzzle” the House of Commons and silence those who are “genuinely interested in having their say” on a “delicate and divisive” matter. He said he understood the government wanted to move quickly and to avoid what he called ideological filibustering by the Conservatives, but argued that a public conversation was required.
Fraser said MPs have had “ample opportunity” to debate the issue in Parliament and through a joint study by several parliamentary committees, and that debate will continue during the committee stage. He also pointed to the March 17 deadline, saying that if the law is not adopted expeditiously, Parliament will face a mandated timeline in the Criminal Code on another issue with greater consensus.
The government has repeatedly postponed the date on which mental illness could become a qualifying condition for an assisted death, and it asked a special parliamentary committee to study the question. That committee concluded in June that people suffering solely from a mental illness should be excluded indefinitely from accessing MAID.
Under current federal law, a medically assisted death is available to people who are at least 18 years old, have a serious and incurable physical illness, disease or disability, and are in an advanced or irreversible state of decline. They must be able to make a voluntary request and give informed consent at the time the procedure is administered. An advance request would allow a person with a degenerative condition, such as dementia or ALS, to ask that an assisted death be carried out once they no longer have the capacity to consent.
Under Bill C-41, provinces and territories would decide whether to fulfil advance requests through their own health systems, and whether to enact the necessary legislation. Quebec is the only province that already has an advance-request regime in place. Alberta has passed legislation to bar the use of advance requests. Fraser has said he is somewhat concerned about a patchwork of rules across the country, but that he would be more concerned about extending access without safeguards, including those that provincial governments must legislate.
The federal bill includes safeguards for advance requests, among them a requirement that two independent medical or nurse practitioners confirm the person meets the criteria. The procedure would not be administered if the person shows, by words, sounds or gestures, refusal or resistance to it. Fraser said he wants the bill to pass the House of Commons before the sitting ends in December, which he said would leave ample time for the Senate to consider it.
17
